Thursday, July 6, 2017

Alex Rosenberg on Beliefs



Alex Rosenberg is an atheist and philosopher of science who maintains that if naturalism is true, then beliefs cannot exist. (How he can believe this is a mystery to me.) He is also the author of "The Atheist's Guide to Reality."Anyway, here is his argument:

1: If naturalism is true, then beliefs are brain states.
2: Brain states are physical configurations of matter.
3: Therefore, if naturalism is true, beliefs are physical configurations of matter.
4: In order to qualify as beliefs proper, they need to have the property of intentionality (i.e. to refer to or be "about" something)
5: Physical configurations of matter cannot, in virtue just of its physical structure, composition, location, or causal relation, be “about” another configuration of matter in the way original intentionality requires.
6: Therefore, if naturalism is true, beliefs cannot be "about" anything.
7: Therefore, if naturalism is true, there are not beliefs.
8: Naturalism is true.
9: Therefore, there are not beliefs.

and 

10: If there are not beliefs, then there are not true or false beliefs either.

More on the subject:

Physical things have no meaning in themselves. As a physical object a painting is an ordered collection of pigment and oil on rough cloth. It isn't about anything. But as an object of contemplation at a painting is about something. It has a subject matter to which it refers. The properties of physical things do not point to anything beyond themselves. This is in stark contrast to mental properties. Beliefs, fears, and thoughts are all about something. You can believe the earth is round. You can fear spiders. You can remember the Mount Rushmore. These mental properties are about the earth, spiders and Mount Rushmore. But the earth, spiders, and Mount Rushmore as physical things are not about anything.

The cornerstone of naturalism is physical reduction. Yet intentionality cannot fit into naturalism. Alex Rosenberg is fully aware of this. And yet he does not let this shake his conviction that everything is physical. Instead his intellectual commitment to atheistic naturalism forces him to admit the inherent nihilism of that position.


My thesis was based on semiotics and the relationship between signs and the signified. It occurred to me that since signs, as physical artifacts, had no inherent meaning that other physical properties such has brain-states also had no inherent meaning. From a purely objective point of view meaning must be assigned to physical systems from the outside via intellection. I have not made up my mind as to whether meant the absence of an epistomic link or an ontological one. Either way mental properties cannot be reduced to physical ones.

I came across Jime's blog some time ago and learned about Alex Rosenberg's argument. It seemed to present the thesis in a much more succinct way. I also found it interesting that a self-avowed atheist would present the same idea, so I posted it to see what others thought.


And even More:



(21st April 2013, 15:34)whateverist Wrote:...Brains states which underpin beliefs aside from being configurations of matter are already about something. Similarly if I write out a "Spare any change?" sign on a scrap of paper, the piece of paper is just a piece of inert material, compositionally. But now it also conveys my belief that someone is going to throw me some coin, which is my intention.
In your example, the paper does not in itself have meaning. It must be interpreted and assigned meaning from the outside. If your note is written in English it will have no meaning to someone who only knows Chinese. Likewise a brain-state, as a physical thing, has no meaning unless one is assigned to it. When you say conveys your intention, what then is the ontological status of your intention. Is the intention a thing in and of itself, conveyed first by your brain then transferred to paper? This implies something independent of both your brain and the paper that has been transferred. What is that thing?


Harmonization, I don't know.

I while back I made my own attempt at harmonization of the resurrection accounts:

Each of the Gospel accounts report events from the perscpective of the four writers. Where one writer glosses over certain happenings, the other writers supply the details. The four Gospel accounts compliment each other, and taken together, give us a more comprehensive picture of what happened. No Gospel account directly contradicts any of the others. I made a side-by-side comparision of all four and assembled for you the followings narrative.

The guards watch dumbfounded as an angel uses an earthquake to roll away the stone that had sealed the tomb. The guards flee in terror. Mary Magdelalene, Mary mother of James, Joanna, and other unnamed women go to visit the grave. 

Matt 28:2-4 is the only Gospel account to supply details about the guards and the earthquake.
John 20:1 focuses on Mary Magdelalene to the exclusion of the other woment in the party.
Matt 28:1 also focuses on Mary Magdelaene, incidentally mentions Mary mother of James, but not the other women.
Luke 24:10 identifies Joanna as one of the women in the party.

When they arrive they see that the tomb has been opened and they see a youth sitting on the stone. The child tells them that Jesus isn't there because he had risen and that they should tell the disciples. The youth also tells them that Jesus will meet them in Galelie.Some or all of the women then enter the tomb. Two men suddenly appear. The men say, "He is not here...". The women bow to the ground in reverence. Then they go back to some the disciples reporting what the youth and the two men had said. Mary Magdalene appears to remember what was said but still believes someone carted away the body.

None of the disciples present believe the women. Mary Magdalene leads Peter and John back to the tomb so they could see for themselves..John rushes ahead but doesn't enter. He watches from the outside as Peter goes into the tomb and examines the burial wrappings. While John and Peter are examining the tomb, the two men appear to Mary again. This time Jesus is with them although she doesn't recognize him until he says her name.

Matt 28:7 records what the youth said then skips all the intervining details and goes direct to the appearence in the upper room.
Mark 16:7 also records the encounter with the youth, but omits the details of the two men. Mark also skips over Peter, John's and Mary's visit.
Luke 24:12 focuses on Peter as the central character to the exclusion of John and Mary.
John 20:8-18 adds all the details relating John and Mary Magdalene.

Meanwhile, two of the disciples, one named Cleopas, are walking to Emmas, They meet a man on the road and have dinner with him and discuss the events of the Passion. Suddenly the two disciples finally recognize the man as the risen Christ.

Mark 16 and John 20 do not record this particualar visitation.

Finally, everyone is united for dinner. Peter and John report to the rest that the tomb was empty. The two disciples returning from Emmau chime in and report their encounter with Jesus. And the reports of Mary Magdalene and the other women are fresh in their minds. Everyone is confused. The remaining disciples, including Thomas, don't believe any of it until finally Jesus appears within their midst to clear up the events of the day.

And that is how it happened...

Those who say that the four Gospel accounts conflict have not taken the time to complete the puzzle. I have done so for you, so that you may understand the story in its entirety.
I cannot say that I agree entirely with this post any more. But I'm keeping it as a relic of my previous philosophical musings:


The “Problem of Evil” as traditionally presented:

Question: Can an all-powerful and all-good God create an all-good world?
An all-good God would try to create an all-good world.
An all-powerful God would be able to make an all-good world.
The world is all-good.

Orthodox monotheism, as commonly understood, argues that all three statements are true. Like others on AF, I find traditional appeals to free-will and the ‘best of all possible worlds’ defenses less than compelling. The inability of orthodoxy to adequately defend against the problem of evil follows from its misunderstanding of the nature of God.

In this thread I will present a preliminary attempt to acknowledge the apparent evil present in the world within a theistic framework. I believe this framework more closely reflects God as presented in the bible without the speculations of the Scholastics. I will do so from the perspective of a Panenthestic, neo-Platonic interpretation of Emanuel Swedenborg’s theology, widely considered a heretical position by the larger Christian community. I have capitalized terms associated with absolutes, ultimates and universals to distinguish them from approximates or appearances of the same.

Unlike Pantheism, which means ‘the natural world is God’, Panentheism means ‘the natural world is within god’. Panentheism considers God to be all of reality, or the All. The All includes a natural aspect, but also includes other aspects inferred from the natural. In Panentheism (or at least the kind I advocate) creation simply means the process of substance taking a particular form. This conforms to Swedenborg’s assertion that God created the natural world ‘out of Himself’, as opposed to ‘out of nothing’. (Out of nothing, nothing comes.) 

God is defined as the Supreme Being, or the All, understood as the unity of Ideal Form (ultimate Truth) and Primal Matter (universal good). 

Reality is that which is considered self-evident and primary. Objective reality exists independent of human perception. Anything capable of apprehension by the senses of anyone falls with objective reality. Subjective reality is anything apprehensible only by the experience of a specific sentient being. Every real thing has two aspects: formal and substantial. Formal is synonymous with the conceptual, abstract and ‘spiritual’. Substantial is synonymous with physical and material. While form and substance can be thought of as distinct aspects of reality, one cannot exist independent of the other. Every substance has a form and every form has a substance.

The Good is identified with Primal Matter and its essence is Love. The Good subsists in-itself and, as Love, strives for completeness and coherence. Evil is a local lack of these qualities, i.e. imperfection and corruption. The Good is the highest of all goods from which all lesser goods are derived. The goals of goods are called goodwill. The actions of goods are called good deeds. The results of goods are called virtues.

The True is identified with Ideal Form and its essence is Wisdom. The True is the manifestation of the Good’s completeness and coherence. Things that appear true can be found within and conform to the Ideal Form. What we identify as true are those things that, in our estimation and judgment, accurately embody forms taken from the True. 

Where orthodoxy sees Omniscience, I see subjective experience active at all scales of reality. As an advocate of pan-psychism, I consider proto-consciousness (‘knowing’ at the smallest scale) as a universal aspect of reality. Self-awareness becomes apparent when substance reaches the level of complexity needed to bind proto-conscious monads into higher forms that more closely approximate the Ideal Form. The soul of a sentient being is the unity of that beings highest formal attributes with the smallest necessary substantial basis. Since the All is the largest scale manifesting the highest degree of complexity, the totality has within it all consciousness. God with respect to His understanding is the ‘knowing that is within all’. 

Where orthodoxy sees Omnipotence, I see the universal self-organizing power (potency) within the Good to subsist and support the subsistence of lesser goods. The All strives to create wholes that reflect its own coherence and completeness. Because the All is complete and coherent, no lack can be found within it. Thus evil cannot be ascribed to the All. Since only the All can be a perfect unity, i.e. the One, all creations within the all can only partially embody the Good of the All. Thus all creations, as partial goods, express some lack of good. These lacks are called evils. Because evils are the absence of the good that would make something a perfect unity, evils are really nothing at all, just fantasies without substance or form. 

Thus evil is not a universal state that we can ascribe to the All, but rather we find evils within local conditions. This is what the statement by Heraclitus that “For God everything is good, but for mortals there is good and evil” means to me.


And some clarifications:


I am no longer a pan-phycism advocate.

Wednesday, July 5, 2017

Unbelievable? Moral Realism and My Comments

http://cfvod.kaltura.com/pd/p/618072/sp/61807200/serveFlavor/entryId/1_s68pobxk/v/1/flavorId/1_g010t8pa/name/a.mp3

During Mike Rand’s “interrogation” I listened with great interest to your defense of objective morality. You did a very good job of it. As for me, it has been my great pleasure, after intense internet debate with agnostics and atheists over many years, to refine the issues (IMHO) to a simple and succinct presentation.
First, I start with a seemly benign epistemological principle: Things are as they appear to be until shown otherwise. Now it appears that there are universally applicable principles of justice. The excellent example of you gave, killing others in cold-blood, resonates with every sound-minded human being. In Folsom Prison Blues, Johnny Cash artistically invokes this clear injustice when he sings, “Well I shot a man in Reno just to watch him die.”
In the absence of any valid objection or compelling defeater, belief in moral facts is warranted. But is there such a defeater? The one most commonly proposed, also given by your guest, Mr. Rand, is the variety of moral codes and the shifting of ethical sentiments over time. This objection simply does not work. There is a difference between knowing that a thing exists and knowing what a thing is. For example, when a curious child gets birthday package he knows there is a gift inside, but he can only make an educated guess about what it is by shaking and weighting the package. Clearly, many different moral codes and ethical principles have been proposed and debated for as long as humans have existed. However, a lack of consensus, much less any definitive agreement, about the epistemological status of apparent moral facts does not undermine the ontological claim that there are actual moral facts. Indeed, the very notion that there should (emphasis on should) be norms about right and wrong is itself a generally acknowledged moral fact.
Since this objection, the variety of moral systems and sentiments, is based on conflation of an epistemological claim and an ontological one, it cannot serve as an adequate defeater for the moral argument. Therefore, since no other compelling objection seems to be in the offing, it is right and proper for people to believe that morality is objective, even if, they cannot agree on the specific prohibitions and obligations it would include.
Congratulations on your book. I hope it does well.

And my response to a challenging reply:

The basic objection was that a category can only be know from specific examples...

...I appreciate your reasoned tone and close reading of my post. You make some excellent points.

I’m not certain that the way you apply “ontology following epistemology” directly applies. I am not saying that if there is at least one instance of a moral fact, then people can be assured that moral facts actually exist; but rather, that we have moral experiences, the ever present sense that some things are right and wrong, independent of what we consider moral at any given moment. That gives warrant to the belief that there is a non-empty set, or category, called moral facts…even if no one can identify a specific and unequivocal moral fact.

In this respect moral realism is not different from, say, mathematical realism. Someone can reasonably believe circularity is real, even though no instance of a perfect circle physically exists. I do not see this as particularly problematic for any ethical tradition, Christian or otherwise, that admits some notion of degrees of perfection.

Why I am a Christian

Each time in the past I have given basic summaries. I feel each leaves out little bits of insight. Having a bit more time perhaps I can be more thorough this go around. First, a general comment: conversion experiences do not happen in a cultural vacuum. When people turn to religion, they gravitate to what is most familiar. Midwesterners do not generally turn to Islam or Hinduism. Middle Easterners do not generally turn to Shinto or Rastafarian practices. My own denomination, Second Advent or New Church, does not find this problematic, which is another topic entirely.

As for myself, I was raised in a Christian home. The community church did not “feed” me. Church was a Sunday ritual. Youth group was a social club. We were taught blind faith without doctrine. As I came of age, I couldn’t just believe in something because the adults said so. From middle school through high school I learned about the major philosophers, in general, and the existentialists in particular. My exposure was pretty shallow. I still believed in Jesus, but considered it an “irrational stance” within an absurd world. In college I loaded up my electives with philosophy courses and ended up one credit hour short of a minor. In my junior year of college, being an atheist in practice I accepted that I was an atheist in belief.

For a while I became very interested in the psychologist Abraham Maslow. That really hit home. Part of my mental make-up is a propensity toward “peak experiences.” It doesn’t take much: a warm cup of coffee on a quiet rainy day, a long run by the lake in the winter, etc. While the religious describe this in spiritual terms, I considered it a curious and wonderful psychological experience that gives you a calm sense of place in the world. And I actively pursued it. I read about the many of the mystics to learn from their practices; St. John of the Cross’s “dark night of the soul”, St. Teresa’s agony that was indistinguishable from ecstasy, William Blake’s art and poetry, and, yes, the visions of Swedenborg. I learned to meditate, mostly mindfulness, and found that shedding contingent aspects of self to find the irreducible personal existent comes naturally to me. I still attribute most of this effect to the “relaxation response” used by many athletes.

All this time, I never lost interest in philosophy of mind. From college the issues started by Descartes and chewed by Ned Block, Dennett, Churchland, Nagel, and Chalmers remained fresh. Compared to my own visceral meditative and flow experiences, then and now, the conclusions of the analytic philosophers seem to be missing something essential. Because I am heavily invested in the visual arts, I have also been profoundly influenced by semiotics. 

My first step back toward the Christian faith came from this mix of transcendent experiences, philosophical speculation, artistic practice, fighting for human dignity, and a commitment to existential freedom. I had the start of fairly coherent intellectual framework for expanding my understanding of reality. I slowly build on that, including my participation with AF. 

The above sufficiently explains my turn toward a more spiritual worldview. It does not explain how I became a Christian. As I said in the beginning, I lacked much doctrinal education. From my philosophical perspective most of the traditional doctrines made no sense to me: God-in-Three-Persons, Jesus as both man and God, etc. Orthodox belief isn’t for me, I can accept some mystery just from being human, but the paradoxes of traditional doctrines are too blatant to overlook.

All that changed after a personal and unexpected revelatory experience. I was working on a house project in the basement when I was overcome by a profound sense that the biblical text was somehow actually alive, every “jot and tilde”. And I remembered hearing this idea before in the writings of Swedenborg. I gave him a second look. To my surprise it started to make sense. He explained the Holy Trinity, Christ’s mission, and spiritual reality in a logical way. And for the first time really the Holy Scriptures opened up for me, filled with riches and insights on so many levels. 

I would be remiss in my duty if I did not mention that throughout my conversion I became increasingly aware of the sin in my life. Many Christians describe hitting bottom and turning to Christ. I cannot say that I had one defining moment but I did have several dark nights of the soul when I was forced to confront the lingering sins from my atheistic perspective. These sins included permissive attitudes toward libertines, approval of licentious and self-destructive behaviors, scoffing at people with simple faith, and no shortage of bad habits. I think that’s the regenerative process described by St. Paul as “working out my salvation with fear and trembling.” 

For me God is no longer an abstract concept. He is a fundamental aspect of reality, obvious once understood, hidden in plain sight, or as the hymn says, “Tis only to splendor of light hiddeth Thee!”

Another Sparing with Jor...

http://atheistforums.org/thread-47143-po...pid1488982
(18th January 2017, 05:14)Jörmungandr Wrote:
(17th January 2017, 16:42)Neo-Scholastic Wrote:What is your explanation for the fact that the universe has a rational order?
Does it have rational order, or does reason find meaning in ordered patterns? Last we visited this subject, you said you were of the "opinion," that our ability to pick out patterns in the underlying chaos of the universe is suggestive of a proscriptive order. Just what is that "opinion" based on?
You at least tacitly acknowledge that people can find ordered patterns the universe. Indeed. And those patterns are extremely precise, highly detailed, and coherent. It seems strange to me that you would dismiss the whole of human knowledge as casually as one would a pancake with the face of Jesus on it. Your answer to why the universe appears to be ordered is simply that it appears to be so. That is not really an answer. It’s empty rhetoric. 

On what do I base my opinions about proscription? Why not say that science only produces are models and descriptions? My opinion is based on another question: what is the nature of the thing described? With respect to natural science, inductive reasoning adequately justifies the belief that the apparent order of the physical universe reflects an actually ordered fundamental reality, since, as I previously mentioned, the descriptions only become more detailed, the findings more precise, the models more nuanced, and the predictions more accurate with every improvement in the experimental and conceptual tools Mankind uses observe and interpret the natural world.

There appears to be an epistemological limit with respect to whether reality, at the most fundamental level, is orderly or chaotic. Beyond that limit people can only guess. I acknowledge as much. That is not to say that the question is esoteric. Each guess, or existential choice, comes with a price. I only ask that people recognize the implications of their choice with respect to important values, such as human rights, personal autonomy, meaning & purpose, and their obligations to others. As a general rule I think you understand and accept those implications.

(18th January 2017, 05:14)Jörmungandr Wrote:
(17th January 2017, 16:42)Neo-Scholastic Wrote:What is your explanation for why people have the rational capacity to discern that order?
Because it is useful to the survival of our species. That's all that evolution requires for there to be a selective advantage to preserving this feature. But you already know this.

That answer doesn’t address the sense of my question. You’re just saying that it works. So what? Many species survive and thrive without rationality. Claws work because they are sharp. Camouflage works because it blends with the background. What is it about reason that makes it work? I say, reason works because it produces real knowledge of external reality. You frequently seem to pooh-pooh this notion. The senses are unreliable, you say. Our interpretations are biased, you say. And that is true to some extent. So also is our sense of time unreliable and subjective. That is why we invented clocks and calendars to correct our limitations. In the same way, we have developed conceptual tools from symbolic logic to the modern scientific method to overcome fallacious thinking and interpretive bias. We have developed physical tools, from rulers to microscopes, to supplement and correct the senses. But none of that matters, you say, if the efficacy of the tools themselves is suspect since they are the products of conceptual bias and deceptive senses That kind of radical skepticism leads nowhere. And it comes with a price, a very steep one at that.

(16th January 2017, 23:19)Natachan Wrote:Evidence is anything that is concordant with and exclusively indicative of one conclusion.
That rules out the majority of scientific theories.

Can We Know Reality As It Is?





Here are my comments about the above video: 

First, people are indeed susceptible to illusions. As a semi-professional oil painter, I know all about the techniques artists use to trick the eye. Despite being initially fooled, viewers can know that what they see is illusion and still delight in the tenaciousness of its affect. The teenager looking at a lingerie catalogue never mistakes the printed image for the real life model. Unlike the beetle, he knows his arousal is based on fantasy. Continued observations may not dispel some compelling misperceptions but they can reveal some illusions for what they are. The lecturer rhetorically states that “we are blind to our blindness” but I don’t think he truly believes that. In fact he uses other more refined observations, mathematical models, and logic to reveal areas of ‘blindness’. 

Secondly, there is ambiguity about his use of the phrase “as it really is.” While there may be, and likely is, an unbridgeable chasm between phenomena and nomena that does not mean that the interactions between them are arbitrary. All the reasons I listed before (about the accuracy, precision and detail of our scientific models) justify the belief that those interactions are instead ordered by necessity. So while the phrase “as it really is” can apply to mistaking beer bottles for mates, it would not undermine induced knowledge that the world “really is” rationally ordered. You can have both. 

Next. At the end, around 20:00, the lecturer explicitly states his belief that logic and mathematics are not simply perceptual hacks. Many skeptics advocate otherwise. You point to problems like the Liars Paradox to support your belief that reason itself cannot be trusted. It too, you have said, is an evolved hack to enhance fitness. Your claim is that people cannot even have certainty about basic rules of thought like the Principle of Non-Contradiction or the Law of Identity. That is a self-defeating position. 

Also, I do not often refer to claims from special revelation but I think they have relevance. The content of the videos confirm Christian beliefs taken from Scripture, i.e. the sensual world is illusory and often prevents us from seeing spiritual reality, or as the lecturer would say “as it really is” Specifically:

“For now we see in a mirror, darkly…” – 1 Cor 13:12
“You cannot see my face, for no one may see me and live.” – Ex 33:2
“And he was transfigured before them and His face shown like the sun and His clothes became white as light.” – Matt 17:2
“…Jesus Himself came up and walked with them, but they were kept from recognizing Him…then their eyes were opened and they recognized Him….” Luke 24:15,16

And for what it is worth:

“Angels have no notion or idea of time and space…” – Emanuel Swedenborg, HH 162
“If the doors of perception were cleansed everything would appear to Man as it is, Infinite.” – William Blake.
“The name that can be named is not the enduring and unchanging name.” – Lao-tzu

I mention these references both Scriptural and from mystical writings because all of them acknowledge a clear distinction between the nomenal and phenomenal. The categories of time and space and physicality are other than what we suppose. At the same time, the point of these sources  is that dispelling these illusions of fleshly incarnation reveals a divine order that is more fundamental (or spiritual) reality. They encourage people to look beyond the veil of illusions to see reality “as it really is.”